Hispanics Get to Vote Six Times in New York

All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” – Animal Farm

Residents get 6 votes each in suburban NY election

By JIM FITZGERALD –  AP   – via Yahoo News

PORT CHESTER, N.Y. – Arthur Furano voted early — five days before Election Day. And he voted often, flipping the lever six times for his favorite candidate. Furano cast multiple votes on the instructions of a federal judge and the U.S. Department of Justice as part of a new election system crafted to help boost Hispanic representation.

Voters in Port Chester, 25 miles northeast of New York City, are electing village trustees for the first time since the federal government alleged in 2006 that the existing election system was unfair. The election ends Tuesday and results are expected late Tuesday.

Although the village of about 30,000 residents is nearly half Hispanic, no Latino had ever been elected to any of the six trustee seats, which until now were chosen in a conventional at-large election. Most voters were white, and white candidates always won.

Federal Judge Stephen Robinson said that violated the Voting Rights Act, and he approved a remedy suggested by village officials: a system called cumulative voting, in which residents get six votes each to apportion as they wish among the candidates. He rejected a government proposal to break the village into six districts, including one that took in heavily Hispanic areas.

Furano and his wife, Gloria Furano, voted Thursday.

“That was very strange,” Arthur Furano, 80, said after voting. “I’m not sure I liked it. All my life, I’ve heard, `one man, one vote.'”

It’s the first time any municipality in New York has used cumulative voting, said Amy Ngai, a director at FairVote, a nonprofit election research and reform group that has been hired to consult. The system is used to elect the school board in Amarillo, Texas, the county commission in Chilton County, Ala., and the City Council in Peoria, Ill.

The judge also ordered Port Chester to implement in-person early voting, allowing residents to show up on any of five days to cast ballots. That, too, is a first in New York, Ngai said.

Village clerk Joan Mancuso said Monday that 604 residents voted early.

Gloria Furano gave one vote each to six candidates. Aaron Conetta gave two votes each to three candidates.

Frances Nurena talked to the inspectors about the new system, grabbed some educational material and went home to study. After all, it was only Thursday. She could vote on Friday, Saturday or Tuesday.

“I understand the voting,” she said. “But since I have time, I’m going to learn more about the candidates.”

On Tuesday, Candida Sandoval voted at the Don Bosco Center, where a soup kitchen and day-laborer hiring center added to the activity, and where federal observers watched the voting from a table in the corner.

“I hope that if Hispanics get in, they do something for all the Hispanic people,” Sandoval said in Spanish. “I don’t know, but I hope so.”

FairVote said cumulative voting allows a political minority to gain representation if it organizes and focuses its voting strength on specific candidates. Two of the 13 Port Chester trustee candidates — one Democrat and one Republican — are Hispanic. A third Hispanic is running a write-in campaign after being taken off the ballot on a technicality.

Campaigning was generally low key, and the election itself was less of an issue than housing density and taxes.

Hispanic candidates Fabiola Montoya and Luis Marino emphasized their volunteer work and said they would represent all residents if elected.

Gregg Gregory gave all his votes to one candidate, then said: “I think this is terrific. It’s good for Port Chester. It opens it up to a lot more people, not just Hispanics but independents, too.”

Vote coordinator Martha Lopez said that if turnout is higher than in recent years, when it hovered around 25 percent, the election would be a success — regardless of whether a Hispanic was elected.

“I think we’ll make it,” she said. “I’m happy to report the people seem very interested.”

But Randolph McLaughlin, who represented a plaintiff in the lawsuit, said the goal was not merely to encourage more Hispanics to vote but “to create a system whereby the Hispanic community would be able to nominate and elect a candidate of their choice.”

That could be a non-Hispanic, he acknowledged, and until exit polling is done, “it won’t be known for sure whether the winners were Hispanic-preferred.”

The village held 12 forums — six each in English and Spanish — to let voters know about the new system and to practice voting. The bilingual ballot lists each candidate across the top row — some of them twice if they have two party lines — and then the same candidates are listed five more times. In all, there are 114 levers; voters can flip any six.

Besides the forums, bright yellow T-shirts, tote bags and lawn signs declared “Your voice, your vote, your village,” part of the educational materials also mandated in the government agreement. Announcements were made on cable TV in each language.

All such materials — the ballot, the brochures, the TV spots, the reminders sent home in schoolkids’ backpacks — had to be approved in advance, in English and Spanish versions, by the Department of Justice.

Conetta said the voter education effort was so thorough he found voting easier than usual.

“It was very different but actually quite simple,” he said. “No problem.”

Explore posts in the same categories: suspicious

13 Comments on “Hispanics Get to Vote Six Times in New York”

  1. tgusa Says:

    The judge should be hanged.

    • tgusa Says:

      The other voters in the area sould reject anything to do with the justice system all the way down to turning their law abiding backs on the police. Desperate times call for desperate measures. This judge is a theif he belongs along the border, on the mexican side, permantly. Lets see who needs who most.

    • PB-in-AL Says:

      I agree. That is just freakin’ insane!

  2. tgusa Says:

    Heres a suggestion. Send these people down to the Natioanl park along the Az. border. Have them become greeters. FR; Feds retreat, surrender Natioanal park to Mexican drug cartels. The fact is I don’t go backpacking in the parks anymore, they have been using them to grow weed for a long time now. Boobytraps, tripwires, armed goons, its just not safe and You know that if you defend yourself you will end up behind bars.
    From the Gulf to the AZ border, elections have consequences. Just look what it has done to America already.

  3. Big Frank Says:

    This decision must be appealed in a higher court. It is up to the people who want representation to get their asses out and vote, how simple. No,however that;s too hard, the whining, crybaby, ‘disenfranchised’ Hispanic groups are getting too used to the courts doing everything for them.

  4. Bob Says:

    These judges are beneath contempt They answer to no one but themselves. In stead of helping people win their place in the political system by being the best person regardless of the color of their skin or there national origin, they change the rules to suit their own twisted sense of what fairness should be. After decades of this kind of thinking is pertetuated, is there any question of how a nation as great as America can become a shadow of its former self.

  5. Bob Says:

    Just because a person has a law degree or is a judge or a doctor or even has three advanced degrees… do not be fooled. In no way does it indicate their ability to run their life successfully, let alone yours, mine and everybody elses. Citizen anywhere and everywhere should demand the resignation of such jurists!


  6. While I think the whole this is wrong and very, very stupid I think you might have some of this wrong. I think they said everyone can vote up to six times not just Hispanics. The reason they did it was because they think that the Hispanics that do vote will only use their six votes to vote for other Hispanics while everyone else will just vote six times at random so it might “even everything out”. They assumed that Hispanics would only vote for other Hispanics (because identity politics are only for everyone but strait white men) so they thought this would bring in more Hispanic politicians. It’s still all a lot of BS though.

  7. Bob Says:

    “I’m not sure I liked it. All my life, I’ve heard, `one man, one vote.’”

    And mr. furano’s ‘level of integrity’ dictated that he go ahead and do something that he didn’t feel right about in the first place?

  8. Anne Bach Says:

    One man, one vote. Why are we changing this now? It is unlawful and anyone voting more than once should be arrested!

  9. MARK GRANGER Says:

    You’d better believe that is the way the Presdidential election will happen this coming November. remember the Democratic Voting Battle Cry: VOTE EARLY – VOTE OFTEN!


Leave a Reply to Anne Bach Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: