I read this with a skeptical eye, I have always said muslims fall into two groups-pious practicing muslims (terrorists and their supporters) and backsliders (non-practicing). Nothing in this article has changed my already low opinion of islam or its minions.
Our government thinks they can teach muslims to play nice with others-friggen great. Give um a certificate of achievement and release them back into the wild. Personally, I think it will almost seem to work. Some will be convinced that spending a few more years as American guests is not what they want to do. It is even possible when these minions are released back into the wild they will share stories of nice gentle American guards and their growing respect for them (not likely). I hope that most of these newly trained nicer minions will not prove this experiment an expensive failure by becoming repeat offenders. I also hope to win the lottery someday but I know it is a rip-off and I do not buy tickets.
Where this program will fail is obvious. Nothing will stop any released minion from returning home to a hero’s welcome for having been a mujhid in the first place. Nothing will stop them from spinning yarns of historical daring and great personnel danger (all lies of course). Stories that will quickly give yet another muslimahs son a jihadi fever. Nothing will stop these minions from recruiting, supporting, training or helping the global jihad spread in any numbers of other methods. In short, this is one colossal waste of money, time and effort. If retraining criminals is so easy why don’t we do this at home? Why can’t we be nice to our own violent criminals and change their violent anti social ways with a little money and love?
Hugs for all, courtesy of Uncle Sam.
WHAT I LEARNED AT ‘ANTI-JIHAD U’
By JUDITH MILLER,May 2, 2008, The New York Post
LAST month, I visited one of the largest Islamic schools in the Middle East.
It’s run by the US military – for detainees in Iraq.
The suspected insurgents also participate in discussion programs about Islam – and are being trained to be carpenters, farmers and artists. It’s all part of the US military’s radically new approach to detention in Iraq – an integral part of its counterinsurgency effort.
For the past nine months, Task Force 134 (9,000 personnel from all the uniformed services) has been experimenting with such unconventional initiatives at two large “camps” that hold 23,245 suspected insurgents. The officer in charge is Maj. Gen. Douglas M. Stone, USMC, who oversees civilian detention in Iraq.
The goal is not only to speed up the identification and release of those falsely accused of “jihadi” activity, but also to deradicalize and rehabilitate other detainees. Judging by the early results, the new approach seems to be working – at least for the vast majority. A relatively small hard core probably can’t be safely released anytime soon, but US officers say that the overwhelming majority, probably more than two-thirds, will likely be freed by year’s end.
Of the 8,000 detainees released since last September, only 21 have been recaptured as a result of suspected insurgent activity – a rate officers say is unprecedented. “It means that only 0.2 percent of those detained have returned to the fight,” Stone told me. “At no time in the history of collected data in Iraq do we have anything remotely like this.”
In my five days with the task force, I wasn’t permitted to talk privately with detainees. But I visited both Camp Cropper (near Baghdad) and Camp Bucca (outside Basra). I also sat in on classes – and watched three-member military panels question detainees and review their records to decide their fates. I also interviewed more than a dozen US soldiers and Iraqi teachers, social workers and clerics working in the program. (more…)
Opinionated Infidels